Seniors, Side Effects, and Celebrex: Does This Strong, One-Size-Fits-All Drug Put Seniors, Women, And Others At Unnecessary Risk?
How Medication Marketing Overrides Medical Science
Celebrex, the powerful, top-selling anti-inflammatory
drug, symbolizes the good and bad of medication therapy today. On the one
hand, Celebrex helps millions of people. On the other, it's one-size-fits-all
dosage for degenerative arthritis (osteoarthritis) is unnecessarily strong
for many people, placing them at extra risk of major side effects such as
gastrointestinal hemorrhage, kidney injury, and death.
The risks aren't small. Anti-inflammatory drugs
cause more than 16,000 deaths and 100,000 hospitalizations each year. The
Physicians' Desk Reference states: "Serious gastrointestinal
toxicity such as bleeding, ulceration, and perforation, can occur at any time,
with or without warning symptoms, in patients treated chronically with nonsteroidal
anti-inflammatory drugs (1)." Yet, as
the New England Journal of Medicine warned: "These toxic effects
remain largely a `silent epidemic,' with many physicians and most patients
unaware of the magnitude of the problem (2)."
The risk of gastrointestinal bleeding is somewhat less with newer anti-inflammatory
drugs like Celebrex, but the risk of kidney failure isn't (2A),
and the newer drugs have also been associated with cardiovascular events (2B).
Seniors and Women, Beware!
Seniors (and women) are impacted the most. Why? One major reason is that although seniors are more vulnerable to the toxic effects of anti-inflammatory drugs, they routinely receive the same strong doses as younger, bigger, healthier people. Such methods defy medical sense and common sense, yet the same 100-mg twice-daily dose of Celebrex is indicated for Shaquille O'Neal's arthritic toe, Ally McBeal's tennis elbow arthritis, and Grandma Moses' arthritic fingers, even if Grandma is 90 years old, weighs 90 pounds, and takes nine other drugs.
Medication side effects are a huge problem for seniors, most of whom rely on prescription drugs. Overall, seniors account for about 20% of the population, yet they sustain 39% of drug side effects requiring hospitalization and 51% causing death (3,4). That's why experts repeatedly advise doctors to use caution when treating seniors and, except in acute situations, to start with the lowest, safest medication doses. In my book Over Dose (5), I quote experts, medical journals and textbooks on this point, but here one statement will suffice, because it's from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration:
"There is evidence that older adults tend to be more sensitive to drugs than younger adults, due to their generally slower metabolisms and organ functions. ... The old adage, `Start low and go slow,' applies especially to the elderly (FDA Consumer Magazine, 1997)(6)."
You need to go no farther than Celebrex, an
arthritis drug commonly prescribed for seniors. The 1999 Celebrex package
insert states that "the incidence of adverse experiences tended to be
higher in elderly patients (7)." The 2003
package insert states that "there have been more spontaneous post-marketing
reports of fatal gastrointestinal events and acute renal failure" with
Celebrex in seniors (8).
Here's another reason why seniors should take
lower doses of Celebrex: blood levels of Celebrex rise higher in seniors,
40%-50% higher on average than in younger adults (8).
Higher blood levels mean greater risks. Seniors don't need higher blood levels
of Celebrex for it to work. With a lower dose, they could get the same blood
levels and effectiveness as younger adults. This is important because seniors
are more vulnerable than younger adults to the serious side effects of anti-inflammatory
Women are also impacted by these issues. Celebrex
blood levels rise higher in older women than older men, which the manufacturer
attributes to women's lower weight. Thus, the package inserts recommends that
"for patients of less than 50 kg [110 pounds] in body weight, initiate
therapy at the lowest recommended dose (8)."
That's a good idea, but for osteoarthritis,
the recommended dose is one-size-fits-all. There is no lower dose.
The Devil Is in the Dosage
Why is it so important to use the lowest effective doses of medications? Because 75%-80% of all side effects are dose-related (9,10). Just like with coffee and alcohol, most side effects are a function of the amounts taken, not of the drugs themselves.
Lower medication doses usually have fewer risks
and are sometimes surprisingly effective. In fact, many seniors with arthritis
do fine with the very low doses in the over-the-counter anti-inflammatories
Aleve, Orudis, or Motrin (ibuprofen).
So what is my concern about Celebrex? The Celebrex
package insert advises, "For osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis,
the lowest dose of Celebrex should be sought for each patient (8)."
But how can you do this if the dosage is one-size-fits-all?
Lower doses of Celebrex actually work (11,12),
but because they aren't marketed, most doctors and patients don't know this.
For example, in a large Mayo Clinic study, 50 mg twice-daily of Celebrex was
significantly effective (11). That's 50% less
medication than the standard dose -- and considerably less risk.
Most of the people in this study had severe
arthritis. This suggests that an even lower Celebrex dosage, 25 mg perhaps,
would be enough for people with mild arthritis. In fact, in a decade or so
we'll probably see low-dose Celebrex as an over-the-counter drug. That's exactly
what happened with Motrin, Orudis, and Aleve (naproxen). But why must we wait
a decade to obtain the lowest, safest, effective anti-inflammatory doses?
That's exactly what I asked in my 2003 article in the Annals of Pharmacotherapy:
"Why Aren't Lower, Effective, Over-The-Counter Doses Available Earlier
by Prescription (13)?"
One-Size-Fits-All: A Worsening Trend
Anti-inflammatory drugs introduced in the 1970s and 1980s came in multiple sizes. Motrin came in 300, 400, 600, and 800 mg sizes. Naproxen: 250, 375, and 500 mg. Naproxen 250 mg twice-daily worked for most of my patients. Naproxen 375 mg twice-daily was enough for most of the rest. Only a small percentage required the 500 mg twice-daily dosage.
Studies show that Celebrex is as effective as
naproxen. In fact, it's as effective as the 500 mg dose of naproxen (11).
So Celebrex is very powerful. The problem is, all patients are started with
this powerful dose, the equivalent of the strongest, riskiest dose of naproxen.
You don't get the choice of starting Celebrex at a dose that's equivalent
to 250 or 375 mg of naproxen. Therein lies the problem, because these drugs'
worst toxicities are dose-related, and even the FDA urges doctors to prescribe
the lowest, safest, effective doses.
Marketing over Medical Science.
Why is this happening?
That's discussed at length
Dose, but in short, drug companies market to doctors, who prefer
drugs that are easy to prescribe, allowing them to finish quickly and move
on. Meanwhile, doctors assume that if a drug is recommended one-size-fits-all,
it's okay, because the drug companies have researched it and the FDA has approved
it. This assumption is dead wrong. The system has no direction, regulation
is weak, and marketing factors frequently override medical science.
Such methods may work with other, less vital
commodities, but with medications it has a distinct downside: more than 106,000
deaths and 2,000,000 severe, often disabling side effects in U.S. hospitals
annually (9). If outpatients were included,
the numbers would be even higher. Moreover, side effects drive millions of
people from badly needed treatment every year.
Informed Consent Means Possessing Enough Information to Make an Intelligent Choice
Medications, including Celebrex, help millions of people. But medications are also a leading cause of death and disability. Much of this harm is preventable by using the lowest effective doses that each person requires.
Lower doses don't work for everyone. Some people
require standard doses. Some people require high doses. But many people respond
to lower, safer doses if given the chance. And in my experience, most people
would prefer to at least start with a lower dose; if it isn't effective, the
dosage can always be raised. This is what I call precision prescribing.
This model doesn't apply to some drugs (e.g., some anti-infectives and anti-cancer
drugs), but it applies to most drugs.
However, you and your doctor can't consider
a lower, safer dose of Celebrex if you don't know about it. And you won't
learn about it in the package insert or Physicians' Desk Reference, which
are written by the drug companies. My purpose in publishing Over Dose and
this newsletter is to provide scientifically-sound information about lower,
safer doses of scores of top-selling drugs, information you won't get from
package inserts, the PDR, or the drug industry's saturation advertising or
90,000 sales reps. Newspaper and magazine articles sometimes provide good
information, but often read more like infomercials.
Most people don't like taking medications. If
they must, they prefer taking as little medication as possible. But unless
the healthcare system makes this possible, we will continue over-dosing millions
of people and perpetuating the decades-long epidemic of side effects. Prevention
begins with good information.
If you and your doctor want to try low-dose
Celebrex (do not alter doses yourself), you cannot split the 100-mg capsule.
You and your doctor could consider using Celebrex once-daily instead of twice-daily,
but the effects might not last twenty-four hours.
Another approach is to have a compounding pharmacy
make lower dose capsules. For a fee, many compounding pharmacies will do this
with a doctor's order. If you or your doctor don't have a local compounding
pharmacy, the Professional Compounding Centers of America (800-331-2498; 281-933-6948)
will help you find one.
1. Physicians' Desk Reference, 53th Edition. Montvale, N.J.: Medical Economics Company, 1999.
2. Wolfe, MM, Lichtenstein, DR, Singh, G. Gastrointestinal toxicity of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. New England Journal of Medicine 1999;1340(24):1888-99.
2A. Ahmad, SR, Kortepeter, C, Brinker, A, et al. Renal failure associated with the use of celecoxib and rofecoxib. Drug Safety 2002;25:537-544.
2B. Bing, RJ. Cyclooxygenase-2 inhibitors: is there an association with coronary or renal events? Current Atherosclerosis Reports 2003;5:114-7.
3. Smucker, WD, Kontak, JR. Adverse drug reactions causing hospital admission in an elderly population: experience with a decision algorithm. Journal of the American Board of Family Practice 1990;3(2):105-9.
3A. Montamat, SC, Cusack, BJ, Vestal, RE. Management of drug therapy in the elderly. New England Journal of Medicine 1989;321(5):303-9.
4. Recchia, AG, Shear, NH. Organization And Function Of An Adverse Drug Reaction Clinic. Journal Of Clinical Psychiatry, 1994;34:68-79.
5. Cohen, JS. Over Dose: The Case Against The Drug Companies. Prescription Drugs, Side Effects, and Your Health. Tarcher/Putnam, New York: October 2001.
6. Williams, RD. Medications and older adults. FDA Consumer Magazine, Sept.-Oct. 1997.
7. Celebrex Package Insert. Searle & Co., 1999.
8. Physicians' Desk Reference, 57th Edition. Montvale, N.J.: Medical Economics Company, 2003.
9. Lazarou, J, Pomeranz, BH, Corey, PN. Incidence of adverse drug reactions in hospitalized patients: a meta-analysis of prospective studies. JAMA 1998;279(15):1200-5.
10. Melmon, KL, Morrelli, HF, Hoffman, BB, Nierenberg, DW. Melmon and Morrelli's Clinical Pharmacology: Basic Principles in Therapeutics. (3rd Edition). New York: McGraw-Hill, Inc., 1993.
11. Bensen WG, Fiechtner JJ, McMillen JI, et al. Treatment of osteoarthritis with celecoxib: a randomized controlled trial. Mayo Clinic Proceedings 1999;74(11):1095-105.
12. Hubbard, R, Geis, GS, Woods, E, et al.
Efficacy, tolerability, and safety of celecoxib, a specific Cox-2 inhibitor, in osteoarthritis. Arthritis and Rheumatism, 1998;41(9 suppl):S196[abstract].
13. Cohen, JS. Why Aren't Lower, Effective, OTC Doses Available Earlier by Prescription? Annals of Pharmacotherapy 2003;37(1):136-142.
NOTE TO READERS: The purpose of this E-Letter is solely informational and educational. Theinformation herein should not be considered to be a substitute forthe direct medical advice of your doctor, nor is it meant to encourage the diagnosis or treatment of any illness, disease, or other medical problem by laypersons. If you are under a physician's care for any condition, he or she can advise you whether the information in this E-Letter is suitable for you. Readers should not make any changes in drugs, doses, or any other aspects of their medical treatment unless specifically directed to do so by their own doctors.
If you have questions about your medications or medical care, Dr. Cohen is available for consultation at his office or by telephone.
If you find this article informative, please tell your friends, family members, colleagues, and doctors about www.MedicationSense.com and the free MedicationSense E-Newsletter.